Sell Tiffany Jewelry Online

myGemma is the faster and safer way to sell Tiffany jewelry for the best prices. We provide a streamlined and secure selling service with no fees charged or commissions deducted.

Sell Your Items

Sell Tiffany Jewelry Online

myGemma is the faster and safer way to sell Tiffany jewelry for the best prices. We provide a streamlined and secure selling service with no fees charged or commissions deducted.

Sell Your Items

How It Works

Our process is designed to take as little as 24 hours.

We buy your Tiffany & Co. jewelry directly, no middle-man or online listings involved.

1. Complete the online form

Don’t worry, it’s easy.

Step 1
Step 2

2. Receive your price quote

We will contact you via phone or email.

3. Free, fully insured shipping OR schedule an appointment

We provide free, fully insured shipping to send your items in for a final price. If things don’t work out, we send your items back to you free of charge and fully insured. There is never any obligation to sell.

You also have the option to schedule an in person appointment at our offices in NYC or London.

Step 3

4. Receive your final price

Accept our final offer and we wire the money to you, or mail a check if you prefer. It’s that simple.

Sell Your Items
Mark

Mark

Emre

Emre

Zac

Zac

Talk To A Real Person

Are you on the fence? Have a question? Need some advice?

We're always here to help. Send us a message.

Email Us Call Us

How Much Is My Tiffany Jewelry Worth?

You should be proud to wear your Tiffany Co. jewelry, but when it comes time to sell there can be signs of visible wear and tear. Here are some suggestions to prevent damages and ensure maximum resale value of your items.

  • Prevent Damage: The first recommendation we have is to keep your high quality pieces in a lined jewelry or watch box to prevent your item from becoming scratched, scuffed or broken. These blemishes will lead to a decreased resale value.
  • Keeping The Box: Retain your Tiffany blue box and documentation from your original purchase. This will help any company looking to buy and resell your item retain the maximum value to you. If these are in great condition it will entice future owners of your jewelry to pay better prices.
  • Sell To Luxury Experts: It is important to sell your designer jewelry to luxury experts. At myGemma our team have the expertise necessary to accurate price your pieces.
Sell Your Items

Our Luxury Experts

Louise

Louise Lieblich

Head of Diamonds & Jewelry

Tom Pozsgay

Tom Pozsgay

Head of Watches

Maya Ali

Maya Ali

Head of Handbags

Read What Our Customers Have Said

5 stars

These folks redefine luxury and customer service. I used to buy/sell to Fashionphile, The RealReal, and Instagrammers all the time, and now I'm a convert to Mark and his team. They've invested hard in a great program while retaining that small business touch and speed.

- A.Y. NOVEMBER 2022

5 stars

Mark was highly effective. He assisted me in an honest way, sending me a quote after evaluating my handbag photos. Once I accepted the price, he emailed a shipping label to me quickly and got the job done with high efficiency. Thank you!

- M.I., APRIL 2023

5 stars

The process was super easy and transparent. They gave us an offer range and stuck by it. We had our money less than 24 hours after we accepted the final offer.

- A.R., JUNE 2023

5 stars

It was a smooth and fast transaction. Highly recommend.

- M.C., JUNE 2023

5 stars

Very professional with their communication and fast with paying for my item they purchased.

- R.F.. JULY 2023

Read All Of Our Reviews

What We Buy

As leading international luxury buyers, we purchase a wide range of designer jewelry, luxury watches and handbags. This includes the following Tiffany jewelry:

  • Elsa Peretti jewelry
  • Paloma Picasso jewelry
  • Tiffany engagement rings
  • Paperflowers
  • Tiffany Hardware
  • Schlumberger
  • Tiffany T

    • And much more

Join The Club

As a member you'll earn points & exclusive rewards every time you shop and sell.

How It Works
1. For every sale: receive loyalty points worth 5%
2. For every purchase: receive loyalty points worth 5% towards your next transaction

You’ll only pay sales tax on the difference (between the store credit and the purchase price).
Get Started
loyalty program

Our Offices

New York

535 5th Avenue, 11th Floor,
New York, New York
10017, USA

London

28 Cavendish Square
London, W1G ODB, UK