Sell Estate Jewelry

Finding the right buyer to sell your estate jewelry to can be a somewhat challenging experience. The market has complexities and nuances that are best navigated by selecting a reputable and knowledgeable estate jewelry buyer.


At myGemma, we make the process as simple as possible with a streamlined, fast, free way to sell estate jewelry to the experts. Sell estate jewelry online or in person in as little as 24 hours.

Estate Jewelry We Buy

  • Rings
  • Cufflinks & Dress Studs
  • Brooches
  • Earrings
  • Pins
  • Bracelets
  • Necklaces
  • Pendants
  • Watch Chain Charms & Fobs

Estate Jewelry Brands We Are Interested In Purchasing Include:

Cartier, Tiffany, Asprey, Buccelatti, Boucheron, Bulgari, Caldwell, Chanel, Chaumet, Christopher Dresser, David Webb, Faberge, Fouquet, Garrard, Georg Jensen, Harry Winston, Hector Aguilar, Liberty & Co, Marcus & Co, Oscar Hayman Bros, Seaman Schepps, Schlumberger, Shreve & Co, Shreve Crump & Low, Raymond Yard, Rene Lalique, Van Cleef & Arpels and more.

Factors That Determine The Value of Estate Jewelry

  1. Historic period or period significance
  2. Intrinsic value
  3. Condition
  4. Collectability / demand
  5. Rarity

4 Tips For Selling Estate Jewelry

  1. Take photos of your pieces of jewelry
  2. Get multiple price quotes
  3. Gather any paperwork you have on the items
  4. Work with knowledgable and expert estate jewelry buyers

Sell Vintage Estate Jewelry

Vintage estate jewelry is classified as pieces created within the last 100 years, have an age of 20 years or more and have not been mass-produced. The 1930’s to 1980’s represent the biggest category of items that myGemma normally purchases. Most of the jewelry we purchase is collectible in some manner.

Sell Antique Estate Jewelry

Antique jewelry items were made over 100 years ago. Again the items we purchase have become collectible in a certain way. The key aspects that govern pricing are rarity, age, provenance and design. We see a huge variety of items on a monthly basis. It’s a fascinating area of the jewelry market and we often come in to contact with exquisite examples made in the USA and often in Europe. myGemma are Antique Jewelry buyers operating nationwide.

Periods of Estate Jewelry In Order Of Importance:

  • Art Deco
  • Edwardian
  • Victorian
  • Art Nouveau
  • Retro
  • Georgian

Why Sell Estate Jewelry To myGemma?

myGemma is at the very center of the international markets for second-hand jewelry, diamonds and luxury watches. Our team of world-class experts have been in the trade for many years and sold a huge variety of items around the world. So if you are selling an inherited heirloom, your grandmother’s ring or antique jewelry purchased from a fair or store, we can help you.

We are proud of our A+ BBB rating and over 1,000 customer reviews, testament to our strong prices and exceptional customer service. myGemma is a faster and safer way to sell estate jewelry for the best prices.

How Fast Is It To Sell Estate Jewelry?

Whether you choose to schedule an appointment or send your items to us through our secure service, myGemma represents a stress free option when selling estate jewelry of all kinds. You will receive money within 24 hours of accepting our offer or receive a check in your appointment. Either way, our experts and client managers will go out of their way to be informative and helpful.

How Much Is My Estate Jewelry Worth?

We will research each item individually and return as much money to you as possible given the conditions in the domestic and international markets. It’s in our interest to make you a competitive offer.How It Works

Just like your vintage or antique jewelry, our process is unique. We want to give you the most accurate price and make sure that we insure your estate jewelry for the right amount, so we ask that you fill out an initial valuation form. Don’t worry, if things don’t work out, we send your items back to you insured and free of charge.

Factors That Determine The Value Of Estate Jewelry

Historic period or period significance:

Certain style periods have always had a mass acceptance and thus are actively traded globally. Other periods have come and gone in favor and prices have done the same in those areas. One might believe that with great age come great value, this is often not the case. An expert with the ability to trade far outside of his or her local area will understand geographical upticks in value and be willing to pay more in lieu of that ability. Alone with style significance, provenance especially historic will add to value.

What is hot globally? Art Deco & Edwardian

Intrinsic Value:

An untrained eye might view an Antique or Vintage pieces of jewelry by what is known in the trade as “rocks and metal’. Intrinsic or the raw secondary market value of metal and gemstones is the base of determining price. The premium above the intrinsic value lies in the combination of period style, condition, supply & demand, collectability, rarity provenance, original box & recognized brand or hallmarks

This method provides the lowest value for your heirloom piece of jewelry. We view every items intrinsic value on….

  • Are the gemstones original to the piece
  • Are they natural, synthetic or faux
  • Accepted GIA grading standards & formulas to calculated weights
  • Internal lab testing as needed
  • Market & previous auction results & comparisons
  • X-ray testing of the metal to verify quality without damaging the item with filing marks & acid testing


The more any item has been gently worn and kept in pristine condition the greater the premium within the confines of the other judgment categories. If an item has been previously restored or a period mounting reset at one time with more modern gemstones the value is greatly depressed.

Problems Areas:

  • Broken or heavily worn prongs
  • Chipped or missing gemstones
  • Use of lead solder in repair / restoration
  • Overly polished removing details
  • Redesign or remodeling of original period piece
  • Bracelets cut down in length

Collectability / Demand:

As previously mentioned certain period styles have continuously been in demand. Good examples of Art Deco or Edwardian jewelry are highly collectible. While Georgian or arts & craft need to find the right buyer or collector to achieve the best price.

To confuse the out outsider even more, Victorian jewelry which spanned a number of decades has its sweet spots as well as low point in value. Not a lot of earring in collectible era survived in pairs and now have premiums with those that do. Rings were generally worn & abused on a day to day basis. Those better collectible period pieces in great condition are few and far between. We would pay a premium for the rarity of pairs of earrings or nicer jewelry in great condition.

What’s potentially surprising is that pins / brooches in general don’t carry extra value based on fashion. Even though there are plenty of beautiful ones around.


Rarity is a mix of condition of an item and how often the market comes across such an item combined with the frequency we are asked if we have said items for sale.

Rare items by category:

  • Earrings
  • Vintage engagement rings in excellent condition
  • Bracelets measuring 7 inches long (today’s standard)

Rare By Maker:

Cartier, Tiffany, Van Cleef & Arpel, Boucheron, Fouquet, Rene Lalique, Oscar Hayman, Raymond Yard, David Webb