Pre-Owned Tiffany Engagement Rings

For over 100 years, Tiffany engagement rings have been a symbol of everlasting love. After all, who hasn’t dreamed of receiving that little blue box with a breathtaking diamond ring inside?

Pre-Owned Tiffany Engagement Rings

Tiffany & Co. has long been associated with special moments in life. From Sweet Sixteen birthday presents to engagement rings. It is often the brand of choice to celebrate big moments. And, for good reason too.

If you’re in the market for a pre-owned Tiffany & Co. engagement ring, this guide will point you in the right direction.

Pre-Owned Tiffany Engagement Rings

For over 100 years, Tiffany engagement rings have been a symbol of everlasting love. After all, who hasn’t dreamed of receiving that little blue box with a breathtaking diamond ring inside?

But should you buy new or pre-owned? For those considering buying a used and pre-owned Tiffany engagement ring, keep reading to find out where, why and how to do so.

About Tiffany Engagement Rings

First, let’s take a closer look at the history of Tiffany & Co. engagement rings. In 1886, Charles Tiffany founded Tiffany & Co. and revolutionized the engagement ring.

Charles Tiffany travelled the world for the most exceptional gemstones, quickly earning him the title 'The King of Diamonds'. With a strong focus on sourcing and using only the very best gems, he wanted to ensure that these stones were set in a way that allowed them to really shine.

Prior to this, diamonds in engagement rings were bezel set. While this provided a secure setting for the diamond, only the top of the diamond was visible and the rest was hidden. Furthermore, the rings were frequently ornate which only further detracted from the diamond itself.

Looking to create an engagement ring setting that truly showcased the beauty of the stone, Charles Tiffany designed the iconic Tiffany Setting.

He devised a simple, elegant setting with 6 prongs that securely lifted the diamond above the band. With the diamond elevated, light could easily enter the diamond and allow for maximum sparkle.

Over 100 years later, the Tiffany Setting remains the must-have engagement ring setting, emulated by countless jewelers and coveted by brides-to-be around the world.

Why Buy Pre-Owned Tiffany Engagement Rings?

There are plenty of fantastic reasons to purchase a used and pre-owned Tiffany engagement ring.


One of the best reasons to buy a pre-owned Tiffany engagement ring is the price. Second-hand and used jewelry is available for purchase for a fraction of the price of its original cost.

This means that your money will go further by buying pre-owned. Shop our collection of pre-owned Tiffany engagement rings at up to 60% off retail. 


All Tiffany engagement rings are made to the highest of standards and are designed to last. Just because a ring is pre-owned, the high-end materials and craftsmanship that went into creating the engagement ring will not be affected. Once the engagement ring is cleaned and polished, it will look just as great as the day it was bought.


The reality is that the metal and diamond mining involved in making new jewelry has a serious impact on the environment.

It requires huge amounts of fuel and water and produces significant amounts of greenhouse gases and toxic cyanide, polluting land and waterways.

Shopping used rings is a great choice: by opting for used engagement rings you are making an eco-friendly purchase. This alleviates the demand for mining which in turn reduces the damage to our planet.


When you shop pre-owned, you can browse a plethora of used Tiffany engagement ring styles, both current and vintage. So why not opt for a vintage Tiffany engagement ring? These rings are unique and imbued with history.

Shop Tiffany & Co. engagement rings

Where To Buy Pre-Owned Tiffany Engagement Rings?

Looking to buy pre-owned Tiffany engagement rings at exceptional prices? myGemma has you covered.

We are a BBB-accredited business with a wide assortment of used and pre-owned Tiffany engagement rings that have been thoroughly authenticated by our experts.

Shop a wide array of engagement rings, designer jewelry and luxury watches at up to 80% off retail prices. To make our products even more affordable, we provide affordable monthly payments with our partner Affirm, free US shipping and a 14-day return policy.

How To Buy Pre-Owned Tiffany Engagement Rings

Follow these four steps to find your perfect Tiffany engagement ring.

  1. Pick a gemstone: Tiffany is known for their outstanding diamonds, but they also sell engagement rings with vibrant gemstones such as tanzanite and rubies.
  2. Pick a shape: While round diamonds in engagement rings are always timeless, you might also consider a chic emerald, modern pear or romantic heart-shaped diamond. 
  3. Pick a setting: Tiffany’s classic setting is a solitaire diamond mounted on a simple band. But you may decide to opt for a glamorous pavé diamond band for additional sparkle, a diamond halo to make center stone appear even bigger or to add a pop of color with gemstone side stones.
  4. Set a budget: Deciding how much you are looking to spend on an engagement ring is an important decision. Make sure to set a realistic budget that you are comfortable with.
    The good news is that with myGemma, your money will go further. Not only do we offer pre-owned engagement rings at up to 80% off retail, but you can also opt for affordable monthly payment plans through our partner Affirm.

Our Latest Tiffany Engagement Rings