The first thing that comes to mind when hearing the name 'Tiffany' might be their little blue box or perhaps the iconic movie Breakfast At Tiffany’s. In the opening scene, the main character Holly Golightly gazes wistfully in the dawn at the jewels in Tiffany’s window.
If you are looking to buy Tiffany jewelry without breaking the bank, our experts have put together their list of the most affordable Tiffany jewelry.
Top 10 Most Affordable Tiffany Jewelry
1. Return To Tiffany Double Heart Tag Necklace
- Retail: $175
- Average Resale Market Price: $95
One of the most well-known collections, Return To Tiffany pieces are classics you'll reach for over and over again. A duo of two engraved heart tags on a sterling silver chain exudes timeless elegance. Available with one colored heart in the iconic Tiffany blue or you can opt for a red, pink or simple all-sterling silver option.
2. Elsa Peretti Open Heart Necklace
- Retail: $200
- Average Resale Market Price: $95
Designed by the renowned Elsa Peretti, the Open Heart collection represents a celebration of love. With matching accessories, home decor as well as rings, earrings, and bracelets, there's something to suit every style and taste.
The Open Heart Necklace mimicks Peretti's organic style and is a delicate, beautiful piece made from sterling silver that is perfect for everyday wear.
3. Bow Charm Bead Bracelet
- Retail: Was $250 (Discontinued)
- Average Resale Market Price: $150
Wrap your wrist like a beautiful present in sterling silver beads topped off with a sterling silver bow. No longer available in boutiques, this piece is exclusively available on the pre-owned market.
This is a great addition to every bow lover's jewelry collection that will add a subtle preppy touch to your look.
4. Tiffany 1837 Cuff Bangle
- Retail: $390
- Average Resale Market Price: $195
This sterling silver cuff embraces refinement with unique details. Engraved with 1837, the year Tiffany & Co. was founded, plus 'T&Co'. at the center and '925' on the other side, the bangle's curves showcase a stunning sleekness.
A great neutral addition for layering or for those who want something simple and sophisticated.
5. Elsa Peretti Bean Design Pendant
- Retail: $400
- Average Resale Market Price: $250
Signifying the 'origin of all things' this Bean Design Pendant necklace encompasses chic minimalism. Designed by the infamous Elsa Peretti, this sterling silver piece comes in a variety of sizes on a delicate chain.
From a simple everyday staple to a unique piece to add to a more layered look, this necklace is a versatile addition to your jewelry collection.
6. Tiffany HardWear Micro Link Bracelet
- Retail: $425
- Average Resale Market Price: $250
This unique bracelet comes from the Tiffany HardWear collection that takes inspiration from New York City, where the brand's headquarters are.
Playing 'with tension, proportion and balance', this bracelet encompasses connected gauge links in sterling silver. In multiple sizes, this piece can be worn alone for a bold statement or layered for a more high-fashion look.
7. Tiffany Infinity Bangle
- Retail: Was $500 (Discontinued)
- Average Resale Market Price: $350
A timeless emblem, the Tiffany Infinity Bangle captures the feeling of continuous 'connection, energy and vitality' that this collection represents. Bangles are a closet staple and Tiffany’s options include various metals and sizes.
Slip this one over your wrist to rock a casual day outfit or to complement fashionable evening attire. You can only find this piece on the pre-owned market.
8. Paloma Picasso Olive Leaf Pearl Earrings
- Retail: $575
- Average Resale Market Price: $350
The leaves of the olive branch, symbolizing peace and abundance, serve as the motif of these elegant and affordable Tiffany earrings. Designed by Paloma Picasso, a leafy olive branch encircles a freshwater pearl on each piece of the beautiful pair.
9. Tiffany T Smile Pendant Necklace
- Retail: $925
- Average Resale Market Price: $695
A signature design from the American brand, the Tiffany T collection features sleek pieces like this Smile Pendant Necklace. The smile showcases two Ts connected to create the smile-like symbol.
A joyful necklace that adds a subtle touch of timeless elegance to its wearer. In multiple gold or silver variations, this piece can be found to suit any style. Also available in bracelet and earring options.
10. Bone Cuff (Sterling Silver)
- Retail: $1,300
- Average Resale Market Price: $900
The gold version of this bracelet, which celebrates female power, was worn in the film Wonder Woman 1984 by the main character's alter ego, Diana Prince.
Created by Tiffany’s own wonder woman, prolific jewelry designer Elsa Peretti, a Capuchin crypt inspired the design and was part of her first collection some 50 years ago.
She crafted the piece to conform to either the left or the right wrist specifically, for wearers’ maximum comfort.
How To Sell Tiffany Jewelry
myGemma's mission has always been to provide a fast and safe way to sell designer jewelry online for the best prices. We believe in honest price quotes, a free service with no hidden fees or commissions deducted.
We are proud of our A+ BBB rating and over 1,000 customer reviews that showcase how we make selling your Tiffany jewelry an enjoyable experience with the very best in customer care.
Our streamlined process can take as little as 24 hours from start to finish:
- Complete our online form
- myGemma will be in touch with a price quote
- Opt to sell online (free, fully insured shipping provided) or for an in-person appointment at one of our offices located in New York or the UK.
- Our experts will assess and value your designer jewelry.
- Get paid or have your items returned free of charge
Where To Buy Affordable Tiffany Jewelry?
The most affordable Tiffany jewelry is pre-owned. Not only is it more affordable, but it is also the most eco-friendly way to buy jewelry.
When shopping pre-owned designer jewelry it is important to buy from luxury experts who have authenticated each and every piece.
myGemma offers a wide range of pre-owned and expertly authenticated designer jewelry, watches and handbags at up to 80% off retail.
- Retail: $425
- Average Resale Market Price: $250
This unique bracelet comes from the Tiffany HardWear collection that takes inspiration from New York City, where the brand's headquarters are. Playing 'with tension, proportion and balance', this bracelet encompasses connected gauge links in sterling silver. In multiple sizes, this piece can be worn alone for a bold statement or layered for a more high-fashion look.
7. Tiffany Infinity Bangle
- Retail: Was $500 (No Longer Available At Retail)
- Average Resale Market Price: $350
A timeless emblem, the Tiffany Infinity Bangle captures the feeling of continuous 'connection, energy and vitality' that this collection represents. Bangles are a closet staple and Tiffany’s options include various metals and sizes. Slip this one over your wrist to rock a casual day outfit or to complement fashionable evening attire. You can only find this piece on the pre-owned market.
8. Paloma Picasso Olive Leaf Pearl Earrings
- Retail: $575
- Average Resale Market Price: $350
The leaves of the olive branch, symbolizing peace and abundance, serve as the motif of these elegant and affordable Tiffany earrings. Designed by Paloma Picasso, a leafy olive branch encircles a freshwater pearl on each piece of the beautiful pair.
9. Tiffany T Smile Pendant Necklace
- Retail: $925
- Average Resale Market Price: $695
A signature design from the American brand, the Tiffany T line features sleek pieces like this Smile Pendant Necklace. The smile showcases two 'T's connected to create the smile-like symbol.
A joyful necklace that adds a subtle touch of timeless elegance to its wearer. In multiple gold or silver variations, this piece can be found to suit any style. Also available in bracelet and earring options.
10. Bone Cuff in sterling silver
- Retail: $1,300
- Average Resale Market Price: $900
The gold version of this bracelet, which celebrates female power, was worn in the film Wonder Woman 1984 by the main character's alter ego, Diana Prince. Created by Tiffany’s own wonder woman, prolific jewelry designer Elsa Peretti, a Capuchin crypt inspired the design and was part of her first collection some 50 years ago. She crafted the piece to conform to either the left or the right wrist specifically, for wearers’ maximum comfort.
How To Sell Tiffany Jewelry
myGemma's mission has always been to provide a fast and safe way to sell designer jewelry online for the best prices. We believe in honest price quotes, a free service with no hidden fees or commissions deducted.
We are proud of our A+ BBB rating and over 1,000 customer reviews that showcase how we make selling your Tiffany jewelry an enjoyable experience with the very best in customer care.
Our streamlined process can take as little as 24 hours from start to finish:
- Complete our online form
- myGemma will be in touch with a price quote
- Opt to sell online (free, fully insured shipping provided) or for an in-person appointment at one of our offices located in New York, Hong Kong, Tokyo, or the UK.
- Our experts will assess and value your designer jewelry.
- Get paid or have your items returned free of charge
Where To Buy Affordable Tiffany Jewelry?
The most affordable Tiffany jewelry is pre-owned. Not only is it more affordable, but it is also the most eco-friendly way to buy jewelry!
When shopping pre-owned designer jewelry it is important to buy from luxury experts who have authenticated each and every piece.
myGemma offers a wide range of pre-owned and expertly authenticated designer jewelry, watches and handbags at up to 80% off retail.
